Class

Spec

Content

•Mythic+•Raid

Difficulty

Boss

Jump to:

Holy Paladin Raid Throughput

The most popular Holy Paladin Throughput in WoW - TWW. Data-driven builds updated daily for Rik Reverb in The War Within 11.1.7. Disclaimers & FAQ

Last updated: 21 hours agoTotal Parses: 24Based on a small sample of top rankings from the last 14 days.

Select a Hero Tree

Top rankings contained multiple hero trees. The data on this page is filtered to whichever hero tree you select.

Throughput

Below is an average breakdown of a small sample of top Holy Paladin rankings for Rik Reverb. You can use this to compare to your own cast counts and uptime to find potential points of improvement. Note that the top logs on some encounters may be skewed towards unnecessary padding that you might not want to emulate.

Healing Breakdown

This table shows healing done to all friendly targets. The top 3 healing abilities are

Eternal Flame,

Holy Shock, and

Dawnlight. The ability that does the most healing per cast is

Beacon of Light, at 146.7M per cast.

Name			Casts	CPM	Avg Cast	Hits	Avg Hit	Crit	Uptime	Overheal	HPS
Eternal Flame	16.79%	66.14M	35.4	9.9	1.68M (192.3K)	40.9 (339.6)	1.45M (20.0K)	40.3% (31.5%)	84.26%	39.78%	308.2K
Holy Shock	15.99%	63.03M	31.4	8.8	2.01M	81.1	777.2K	44.2%	-	53.94%	293.7K
Dawnlight	9.40%	37.03M	-	-	-	1.1K (166.2)	10.4K (153.9K)	34.8%	44.44%	62.59%	172.5K
Beacon of Light	7.09%	27.94M	0.2	0.1	146.68M	4.2K	6.7K	-	-	60.56%	130.2K
Insurance!	6.83%	26.90M	-	-	-	3.7 (190.7)	771.9K (126.0K)	28.2% (31.4%)	81.18%	57.33%	125.4K
Mister Pick-Me-Up	6.30%	24.83M	-	-	-	157.6	157.5K	30.1%	-	18.60%	115.7K
Light of Dawn	6.16%	24.28M	11.9	3.3	2.04M	94.2	257.8K	34.6%	-	61.94%	113.1K
Judgment	5.37%	21.17M	-	-	-	189.7	111.6K	19.6%	-	35.65%	98.7K
Sun's Avatar	5.03%	19.82M	-	-	-	917.1	21.6K	40.5%	-	59.25%	92.3K
Overflowing Light	4.21%	16.61M	-	-	-	89.1	186.4K	-	32.68%	7.26%	77.4K
Holy Prism	3.97%	15.63M	0.8	0.2	20.52M	26.7	586.3K	30.0%	-	57.07%	72.8K
Saved by the Light	3.33%	13.13M	-	-	-	82.2	159.7K	-	23.22%	0.54%	61.2K
Sun Sear	1.53%	6.01M	-	-	-	426.0	14.1K	32.0%	56.88%	58.73%	28.0K
Leech	1.50%	5.92M	-	-	-	65.4	90.5K	-	-	15.15%	27.6K
Veneration	1.46%	5.74M	-	-	-	19.5	293.9K	48.5%	-	39.00%	26.7K
Cyrce's Circlet	1.41%	5.57M	-	-	-	8.5 (95.7)	193.9K (41.1K)	10.7%	7.79%	41.00%	26.0K
Golden Path	1.33%	5.25M	-	-	-	881.7	6.0K	28.7%	-	46.46%	24.5K
Authority of Fiery Resolve	1.01%	3.98M	-	-	-	38.0	104.8K	28.9%	-	48.95%	18.5K
Durable Information Securing Container	0.95%	3.74M	-	-	-	8.1	459.0K	25.7%	9.29%	21.16%	17.4K
Lightbearer	0.83%	3.26M	-	-	-	472.4	6.9K	-	-	24.57%	15.2K
Lay on Hands	0.62%	2.43M	0.4	0.1	6.39M	0.4	6.39M	-	-	37.00%	11.3K
Holy Light	0.61%	2.42M	1.3	0.4	1.81M	1.3	1.81M	17.9%	-	26.60%	11.3K
Seal of the Crusader	0.48%	1.88M	-	-	-	49.0	38.5K	27.9%	-	16.26%	8.8K
Blessing of Summer	0.36%	1.41M	1.1	0.3	1.29M	28	50.4K	-	-	48.68%	6.6K
Flash of Light	0.25%	972.9K	2	0.6	486.4K	2	486.4K	28.6%	-	26.12%	4.5K
Lay on Hands	0.24%	960.4K	0.1	0.0	6.72M	0.1	6.72M	-	-	27.73%	4.5K
Avenging Crusader	0.23%	897.8K	0.2	0.1	3.77M	2.6	342.8K	36.4%	1.99%	31.79%	4.2K
Holy Ritual	0.22%	868.2K	-	-	-	9.1	95.0K	24.5%	-	46.06%	4.0K
Merciful Auras	0.20%	773.4K	-	-	-	19.4	39.9K	21.9%	-	1.88%	3.6K
Tyr's Deliverance	0.08%	314.2K	0.1	0.0	2.20M	5.5	57.4K	32.2%	2.13%	30.77%	1.5K
Bestow Light	0.05%	208.9K	-	-	-	5.6	37.5K	-	3.10%	-	973.2
Sigil of Algari Concordance	0.05%	189.1K	-	-	-	2.5	74.9K	13.2%	0.80%	62.89%	880.9
Eye of Kezan	0.04%	150.1K	-	-	-	1.0	157.6K	25.0%	-	42.77%	699.3
Selfless Healer	0.02%	64.7K	-	-	-	0.3	226.5K	-	-	4.52%	301.5
Lightforged Blessing	0.00%	15.5K	-	-	-	0.1	108.3K	-	-	49.28%	72.1
Light of the Martyr	-3.93%	-15.48M	-	-	-	-	-	-	16.91%	-35.39%	-72.1K
Show More
Total	100.00%	394.05M								50.65%	1.84M

Show All Columns

Healing to Tanks

This table only shows the healing to tank targets. On average, 87.0M total healing was done to tanks.

Name			Casts	CPM	Avg Cast	Hits	Avg Hit	Crit	Uptime	Overheal	HPS
Eternal Flame	22.61%	19.68M	9.9	2.8	1.86M (129.8K)	11.2 (81.4)	1.64M (15.8K)	41.7% (32.7%)	44.85%	34.51%	91.7K
Holy Shock	14.13%	12.30M	6.7	1.9	1.83M	13.8	893.6K	46.7%	-	50.50%	57.3K
Beacon of Light	12.89%	11.22M	-	-	-	2.2K	5.2K	-	-	66.32%	52.3K
Saved by the Light	7.23%	6.29M	-	-	-	41.0	153.6K	-	13.80%	1.09%	29.3K
Insurance!	6.71%	5.84M	-	-	-	2 (38.3)	752.9K (113.1K)	26.2% (31.1%)	34.80%	58.82%	27.2K
Dawnlight	6.43%	5.60M	-	-	-	140 (31.6)	9.9K (133.2K)	34.5%	15.11%	67.39%	26.1K
Judgment	4.20%	3.65M	-	-	-	29.2	125.2K	14.8%	-	7.43%	17.0K
Light of Dawn	3.49%	3.04M	11.9	3.3	255.0K	10.9	278.3K	31.9%	-	59.55%	14.1K
Overflowing Light	3.45%	3.00M	-	-	-	13.7	219.6K	-	6.87%	8.49%	14.0K
Mister Pick-Me-Up	3.21%	2.80M	-	-	-	17.6	159.2K	27.9%	-	15.85%	13.0K
Holy Prism	2.76%	2.40M	0.2	0.1	12.62M	3.2	753.7K	29.9%	-	47.45%	11.2K
Lay on Hands	2.01%	1.75M	0.2	0.1	9.17M	0.2	9.17M	-	-	8.07%	8.1K
Sun's Avatar	1.97%	1.71M	-	-	-	93	18.4K	41.1%	-	66.59%	8.0K
Holy Light	1.44%	1.25M	0.8	0.2	1.64M	0.8	1.64M	18.8%	-	28.45%	5.8K
Cyrce's Circlet	1.08%	941.0K	-	-	-	2.5 (11.6)	195.4K (39.3K)	13.5%	4.22%	47.26%	4.4K
Golden Path	1.05%	910.3K	-	-	-	167.5	5.4K	28.2%	-	50.01%	4.2K
Sun Sear	0.95%	827.5K	-	-	-	60.5	13.7K	31.4%	14.12%	60.64%	3.9K
Durable Information Securing Container	0.79%	683.6K	-	-	-	1.2	574.2K	36.0%	-	12.32%	3.2K
Veneration	0.72%	629.5K	-	-	-	2.0	322.4K	34.1%	-	36.60%	2.9K
Authority of Fiery Resolve	0.60%	521.3K	-	-	-	5.9	88.3K	26.6%	-	57.18%	2.4K
Seal of the Crusader	0.52%	456.1K	-	-	-	11.3	40.2K	29.4%	-	14.51%	2.1K
Lay on Hands	0.44%	384.7K	0.0	0.0	8.08M	0.0	8.08M	-	-	-	1.8K
Blessing of Summer	0.40%	344.2K	0.0	0.0	7.23M	4.3	80.3K	-	-	31.55%	1.6K
Lightbearer	0.33%	286.4K	-	-	-	47.2	6.1K	-	-	32.82%	1.3K
Flash of Light	0.17%	148.2K	0.3	0.1	444.7K	0.3	444.7K	28.6%	-	32.07%	690.6
Merciful Auras	0.11%	100.0K	-	-	-	2.7	37.5K	16.1%	-	-	465.9
Tyr's Deliverance	0.11%	94.3K	0.1	0.0	659.8K	1.3	70.7K	46.4%	1.92%	23.68%	439.2
Holy Ritual	0.11%	91.8K	-	-	-	0.8	120.5K	25.0%	-	35.76%	427.6
Avenging Crusader	0.09%	76.4K	0.2	0.1	321.0K	0.2	401.2K	25.0%	-	57.21%	356.1
Lightforged Blessing	0.02%	14.9K	-	-	-	0.0	312.8K	-	-	-	69.4
Eye of Kezan	0.00%	0	-	-	-	0.1	-	-	-	100.00%	0
Show More
Total	100.00%	87.03M								48.40%	405.5K

Show All Columns

Healing to Non-Tanks

This table only shows the healing to non-tank targets. On average, 307.0M total healing was done to non-tanks.

Name			Casts	CPM	Avg Cast	Hits	Avg Hit	Crit	Uptime	Overheal	HPS
Holy Shock	16.52%	50.73M	31.4	8.8	1.62M	67.3	753.4K	43.7%	-	54.70%	236.4K
Eternal Flame	15.13%	46.47M	35.4	9.9	1.16M (156.0K)	29.7 (258.1)	1.38M (21.4K)	39.7% (31.1%)	84.26%	41.77%	216.5K
Dawnlight	10.24%	31.43M	-	-	-	966.5 (134.6)	10.4K (158.7K)	34.8%	44.44%	61.58%	146.5K
Mister Pick-Me-Up	7.18%	22.04M	-	-	-	140.0	157.3K	30.4%	-	18.94%	102.7K
Light of Dawn	6.92%	21.24M	11.9	3.3	1.78M	83.3	255.1K	35.0%	-	62.26%	99.0K
Insurance!	6.86%	21.07M	-	-	-	1.7 (152.4)	794.0K (129.3K)	30.6% (31.5%)	81.18%	56.89%	98.2K
Sun's Avatar	5.90%	18.10M	-	-	-	824.1	22.0K	40.4%	-	58.38%	84.4K
Judgment	5.71%	17.52M	-	-	-	160.5	109.1K	20.4%	-	39.50%	81.6K
Beacon of Light	5.45%	16.72M	0.2	0.1	87.80M	2.0K	8.3K	-	-	55.44%	77.9K
Overflowing Light	4.43%	13.61M	-	-	-	75.4	180.4K	-	32.68%	6.99%	63.4K
Holy Prism	4.31%	13.23M	0.8	0.2	17.36M	23.5	563.5K	30.0%	-	58.45%	61.6K
Saved by the Light	2.23%	6.84M	-	-	-	41.2	165.8K	-	12.87%	0.02%	31.9K
Leech	1.93%	5.92M	-	-	-	65.4	90.5K	-	-	15.15%	27.6K
Sun Sear	1.69%	5.18M	-	-	-	365.5	14.2K	32.1%	56.88%	58.41%	24.2K
Veneration	1.66%	5.11M	-	-	-	17.6	290.7K	50.1%	-	39.28%	23.8K
Cyrce's Circlet	1.51%	4.63M	-	-	-	6 (84.0)	193.2K (41.3K)	9.5%	7.79%	39.54%	21.6K
Golden Path	1.41%	4.34M	-	-	-	714.2	6.1K	28.8%	-	45.66%	20.2K
Authority of Fiery Resolve	1.13%	3.46M	-	-	-	32.0	107.8K	29.3%	-	47.43%	16.1K
Durable Information Securing Container	0.99%	3.05M	-	-	-	7.0	439.2K	24.0%	9.29%	22.90%	14.2K
Lightbearer	0.97%	2.97M	-	-	-	425.2	7.0K	-	-	23.67%	13.8K
Seal of the Crusader	0.46%	1.43M	-	-	-	37.6	37.9K	27.5%	-	16.81%	6.6K
Holy Light	0.38%	1.16M	1.2	0.3	938.8K	0.6	2.03M	16.7%	-	24.50%	5.4K
Blessing of Summer	0.35%	1.07M	1.1	0.3	974.0K	23.7	45.0K	-	-	52.51%	5.0K
Flash of Light	0.27%	824.6K	2.0	0.5	422.4K	1.7	494.8K	28.6%	-	24.94%	3.8K
Avenging Crusader	0.27%	821.4K	0.2	0.1	3.45M	2.4	338.2K	37.3%	1.99%	27.80%	3.8K
Holy Ritual	0.25%	776.4K	-	-	-	8.4	92.6K	24.4%	-	47.07%	3.6K
Lay on Hands	0.22%	686.7K	0.2	0.1	3.61M	0.2	3.61M	-	-	65.02%	3.2K
Merciful Auras	0.22%	673.4K	-	-	-	16.7	40.3K	22.8%	-	2.16%	3.1K
Lay on Hands	0.19%	575.7K	0.1	0.0	6.04M	0.1	6.04M	-	-	39.03%	2.7K
Tyr's Deliverance	0.07%	220.0K	0.1	0.0	1.54M	4.1	53.1K	27.6%	2.13%	33.43%	1.0K
Bestow Light	0.07%	208.9K	-	-	-	5.6	37.5K	-	3.10%	-	973.2
Sigil of Algari Concordance	0.06%	189.1K	-	-	-	2.5	74.9K	13.2%	0.80%	62.89%	880.9
Eye of Kezan	0.05%	150.1K	-	-	-	0.8	185.4K	29.4%	-	35.08%	699.3
Selfless Healer	0.02%	64.7K	-	-	-	0.3	226.5K	-	-	4.52%	301.5
Lightforged Blessing	0.00%	576.1	-	-	-	0.1	6049	-	-	96.31%	2.7
Light of the Martyr	-5.04%	-15.48M	-	-	-	-	-	-	16.91%	-35.39%	-72.1K
Show More
Total	100.00%	307.02M								51.26%	1.43M

Show All Columns

Damage Breakdown

This table shows damage against all targets in the encounter. The top 3 damage abilities are

Blessing of Summer,

Judgment, and

Holy Shock. The ability that does the most damage per cast is

Blessing of Summer, at 14.7M per cast.

Name			Casts	CPM	Avg Cast	Hits	Avg Hit	Crit	Uptime	Miss	DPS
Blessing of Summer	22.46%	13.29M	0.9	0.3	14.69M	28.3	469.9K	-	-	-	61.9K
Judgment	17.78%	10.52M	20.6	5.8	510.2K	20.6	510.2K	44.8%	-	-	49.0K
Holy Shock	12.58%	7.44M	7.7	2.1	970.6K	12.6	589.7K	46.0%	-	-	34.7K
Holy Prism	9.90%	5.86M	5.2	1.5	1.12M	5.9	991.7K	28.2%	-	-	27.3K
Consecration	8.42%	4.98M	5.3	1.5	933.7K	319.5	15.6K	29.9%	50.62%	-	23.2K
Crusader Strike	7.03%	4.16M	13.3	3.7	313.0K	13.2	314.2K	28.8%	-	0.36%	19.4K
Melee	6.17%	3.65M	60.0	16.8	60.8K	59.7	61.2K	36.6%	-	0.63%	17.0K
Hammer of Wrath	4.77%	2.82M	6.5	1.8	435.4K	6.5	435.4K	47.8%	-	-	13.1K
Sun's Avatar	2.27%	1.34M	-	-	-	32.4	41.5K	39.6%	-	-	6.3K
Shield of the Righteous	2.15%	1.27M	5.3	1.5	240.2K	5.1	246.9K	38.0%	-	-	5.9K
Dawnlight	1.80%	1.06M	-	-	-	7.6	139.4K	35.6%	4.04%	-	4.9K
Mister Pick-Me-Up	1.65%	973.9K	-	-	-	48.1	20.2K	26.7%	-	-	4.5K
Incontinental Hot Sauce	1.08%	636.5K	-	-	-	2.6	247.5K	44.4%	-	-	3.0K
Vile Contamination	0.76%	449.0K	-	-	-	21.0	21.3K	29.9%	29.62%	-	2.1K
Durable Information Securing Container	0.55%	327.4K	-	-	-	2.8	116.5K	30.5%	-	-	1.5K
Turbo-Drain 5000	0.24%	142.0K	-	-	-	2.6	55.2K	33.3%	1.20%	-	661.6
Ratfang Toxin	0.14%	84.0K	-	-	-	0.8	110.3K	31.3%	0.22%	-	391.4
Elemental Focusing Lens	0.10%	58.3K	-	-	-	0.6	94.1K	-	-	-	271.5
Cyrce's Circlet	0.09%	54.9K	-	-	-	1.7	32.9K	14.3%	-	-	255.8
Light's Judgment	0.04%	25.5K	0.0	0.0	535.1K	0.0	535.1K	-	-	-	118.7
Authority of Radiant Power	0.03%	14.8K	-	-	-	0.0	311.4K	-	-	-	69.1
Eye of Kezan	0.01%	3.5K	-	-	-	0.0	73.5K	-	-	-	16.3
Show More
Total	100.00%	59.16M									275.7K

Show All Columns

Healing Done during Sound Cloud

The top 3 healing abilities are

Eternal Flame,

Holy Shock, and

Dawnlight. The ability that does the most healing per cast is

Holy Prism, at 8.5M per cast.

Name			Casts	CPM	Avg Cast	Hits	Avg Hit	Crit	Uptime	Overheal	HPS
Eternal Flame	16.33%	14.62M	6.1	1.7	2.10M (294.7K)	7.0 (67)	1.82M (26.8K)	45.3% (32.9%)	15.46%	31.20%	68.1K
Holy Shock	16.19%	14.50M	5.7	1.6	2.54M	15.5	934.1K	43.9%	-	49.81%	67.6K
Dawnlight	14.93%	13.37M	-	-	-	418 (37.5)	11.7K (225.9K)	40.9%	8.63%	49.13%	62.3K
Sun's Avatar	9.14%	8.19M	-	-	-	336.8	24.3K	41.0%	-	47.56%	38.1K
Insurance!	6.77%	6.06M	-	-	-	0.5 (31.6)	765.8K (179.3K)	27.3% (35.6%)	14.26%	45.43%	28.2K
Beacon of Light	6.62%	5.93M	-	-	-	518.9	11.4K	-	-	52.71%	27.6K
Mister Pick-Me-Up	6.12%	5.48M	-	-	-	29.2	187.8K	33.4%	-	6.29%	25.5K
Light of Dawn	6.06%	5.42M	1.6	0.5	3.35M	13.5	401.0K	33.1%	-	45.45%	25.3K
Overflowing Light	3.37%	3.02M	-	-	-	15.8	191.1K	-	4.74%	0.57%	14.1K
Holy Prism	2.72%	2.43M	0.3	0.1	8.51M	2.9	851.0K	41.7%	-	50.79%	11.3K
Judgment	2.69%	2.41M	-	-	-	18.9	127.6K	19.4%	-	30.98%	11.2K
Saved by the Light	2.35%	2.10M	-	-	-	11.9	176.7K	-	2.61%	0.61%	9.8K
Lay on Hands	1.54%	1.38M	0.2	0.1	7.26M	0.2	7.26M	-	-	28.55%	6.4K
Leech	1.40%	1.25M	-	-	-	12.5	99.7K	-	-	15.53%	5.8K
Sun Sear	1.33%	1.19M	-	-	-	64.9	18.4K	35.4%	9.43%	50.67%	5.6K
Authority of Fiery Resolve	1.18%	1.06M	-	-	-	7.5	140.6K	25.9%	-	31.53%	4.9K
Veneration	1.08%	963.8K	-	-	-	2.6	368.0K	45.5%	-	31.15%	4.5K
Cyrce's Circlet	0.86%	770.6K	-	-	-	0.5 (12.0)	205.8K (56.3K)	10.0%	1.11%	20.41%	3.6K
Lightbearer	0.60%	534.7K	-	-	-	65.1	8.2K	-	-	8.40%	2.5K
Durable Information Securing Container	0.59%	530.3K	-	-	-	1.1	484.2K	17.4%	1.24%	8.22%	2.5K
Holy Light	0.44%	395.8K	0.1	0.0	4.16M	0.1	4.16M	50.0%	-	-	1.8K
Lay on Hands	0.44%	392.3K	0.0	0.0	8.24M	0.0	8.24M	-	-	20.77%	1.8K
Golden Path	0.41%	363.0K	-	-	-	39.0	9.3K	28.7%	-	20.61%	1.7K
Avenging Crusader	0.38%	336.2K	0.0	0.0	7.06M	0.7	470.7K	33.3%	0.51%	18.74%	1.6K
Flash of Light	0.19%	172.4K	0.2	0.1	724.1K	0.2	724.1K	20.0%	-	-	803.3
Holy Ritual	0.19%	169.0K	-	-	-	1.7	101.4K	11.4%	-	37.34%	787.5
Tyr's Deliverance	0.16%	145.7K	0.0	0.0	3.06M	1.6	90.0K	52.9%	0.54%	-	678.7
Merciful Auras	0.15%	130.2K	-	-	-	2.7	48.8K	30.4%	-	7.70%	606.8
Sigil of Algari Concordance	0.08%	69.1K	-	-	-	0.6	121.0K	25.0%	0.24%	38.71%	322.1
Bestow Light	0.05%	45.2K	-	-	-	1.2	38.0K	-	0.59%	-	210.5
Eye of Kezan	0.04%	31.5K	-	-	-	0.3	94.6K	14.3%	-	62.71%	146.9
Seal of the Crusader	0.02%	19.6K	-	-	-	0.5	41.1K	20.0%	-	-	91.1
Selfless Healer	0.01%	12.8K	-	-	-	0.0	268.1K	-	-	-	59.5
Light of the Martyr	-4.43%	-3.97M	-	-	-	-	-	-	4.49%	-32.31%	-18.5K
Show More
Total	100.00%	89.54M								42.51%	417.2K

Show All Columns

Damage Taken from Sonic Blast

Sonic Blast hits all targets in a frontal cone facing the active tank.

Name		Amount		Absorbed	Casts	Hits	Avg Hit	Uptime	Mitigated	DTPS
Sonic Blast	100.00%		7.66M	200.6K	-	4.4	1.75M	-	5.44%	35.7K
Total	100.00%		7.66M						5.44%	35.7K

Show All Columns

Rankings Sample

The data on this page was generated using the following sample of recent top rankings that match your selection.

Name	Date	Duration	HPS
Barciana	Jul 18	2:58	2112348
Bluiish	Jul 23	2:45	2102380
Solarkun	Jul 26	2:56	2080608
Prathe	Jul 23	2:00	2012025
Arvad	Jul 25	3:11	1982539
Franthithco	Jul 20	3:41	1940602
Shockuary	Jul 15	3:24	1891470
Narwë	Jul 20	3:01	1875973
Hoq	Jul 16	3:11	1851812
Senchis	Jul 19	3:15	1851255
Bigbubblenrg	Jul 23	3:39	1825646
Aranzeb	Jul 20	4:14	1819991
Ievo	Jul 27	3:15	1804944
Butwhythough	Jul 25	3:48	1799508
Amaracepally	Jul 24	5:18	1788751
Orielin	Jul 18	8:03	1785916
Ezyl	Jul 17	3:56	1772777
Pälätin	Jul 20	3:31	1769000
Paladrip	Jul 16	2:41	1752028
Aexor	Jul 18	2:59	1747495
Saintadin	Jul 29	3:10	1728764

Advanced Settings

Remove Descriptive Text

What's this?